Hand Well Pumps vs. Electric Pumps: Which is Better?

Hand well pumps and electric pumps both have their advantages and disadvantages. Discover which one is the best fit for your needs with this comprehensive guide.

Share This Post

When it comes to pumping water for your home, there are two main options: hand well pumps and electric pumps. With more and more people looking to get off the grid and out on land, it’s important to know the difference between these two types of pumps and which is right for you. In this blog post, we’ll be taking a look at both hand well pumps and electric pumps, comparing their advantages and disadvantages so that you can make an informed decision about what type of pump is best for your needs. We’ll also give tips on how to maintain each type of pump so that they stay in good working condition. So if you’re ready to learn more about these two popular types of water pumps, let’s dive right in!

Understanding the Differences Between Hand and Electric Pumps

When it comes to pumping water from a well, homeowners have two main options: hand and electric pumps. While both can get the job done, they each offer unique characteristics that make them better suited for certain applications. Understanding the benefits of each type will help you decide which is best for your needs.

Hand water pumps are manual devices that use human force to draw water from a well. This makes them ideal for shallow wells as they don’t require electricity or a motor to work. Additionally, those living off grid or on a homestead tend to opt for this option due to the low cost and flexibility in case the property loses power for any reason. They are also easy to install and operate, making them an affordable solution for those on a tight budget. However, they typically struggle with deep-water wells due to the amount of effort needed to pump the water up from far below ground level.

Electric water pumps use an electric motor to draw water from a well. This makes them ideal for deep-water wells, as the motor can easily power its way through the pressure and depths of deeper wells. Electric pumps are also very efficient, so they are often used in high-demand applications such as farms and large households. However, they require an electrical connection and cost more than hand pumps, making them less suitable for tight budgets or areas where electricity is unreliable or unavailable.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Hand Pumps

Figuring out what the pros and cons of a hand pump can be frustrating, so we’ve compiled a list of each for you to review:

Advantages of Hand Pumps:

Low cost: Installing a hand pump is far less expensive than installing an electric pump or other water supply mechanism.

Portable and easy to install: As they do not require external power sources, hand pumps can be set up quickly and inexpensively in remote areas where electricity is either unavailable or unreliable.

Durable and long-lasting: Hand pumps are designed to be used for many years without requiring additional maintenance or repairs, making them a reliable option for remote areas with limited access to repair services.

Water Safety: Hand pumps can help reduce the risk of contamination by eliminating the need to draw water from surface sources such as rivers, ponds, and streams.

Disadvantages of Hand Pumps:

Limited water supply: As hand pumps rely on human power to extract water from deep underground, the amount of water available is often limited due to physical limitations.

Physical exertion: Pumping a hand pump can require significant physical effort, especially if there is a lot of water to be extracted.

Maintenance: As with any mechanical device, hand pumps require regular maintenance and cleaning to ensure that they continue to function properly over time. This can be a costly and time-consuming process for those in remote areas.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Electric Pumps

Like hand pumps, electric pumps also have a set of their own advantages and disadvantages. You can read what we’ve compiled here:

Advantages of Electrical Pumps:

Low operational cost: running an electrical pump is much more cost-effective than running a gas-powered pump.

Quiet operation: electric pumps are much quieter than gas-powered ones, making them ideal for residential areas.

Longer lifespan: electric pumps typically last longer than their gas-powered counterparts, so they are a great long-term investment.

Low maintenance: electrical pumps require minimal maintenance, making them ideal for those who don’t want to spend a lot of time or money on upkeep.

Versatile: electric pumps can be used with a variety of water sources such as wells, rivers, and lakes.

Disadvantages of Electrical Pumps: 

Limited power: electric pumps are not as powerful as gas-powered ones, so they may struggle in larger wells with a lot of water pressure.

Dependency on electricity: without a functioning power source, electric pumps cannot be used.

Expense: while the initial cost may be lower than gas-powered pumps, the cost of installation is often quite high.

Limited reach: electrical pumps typically have a shorter reach than gas-powered models, so they may not be for deeper wells.

Safety risk: electric pumps must be installed and maintained properly to avoid the risk of shock or fire hazards.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Hand and Electric Pumps

When deciding between a hand well pump and an electric pump, there are several factors to consider. First, consider the location of your well and the availability of electricity. If you live in a remote area without access to electricity, a hand pump may be your only option. Second, consider your physical abilities and the amount of water you need to pump. If you have limited physical abilities or only need to pump small amounts of water, a hand pump may be sufficient. However, if you need to pump large amounts of water or have a deep well, an electric pump may be a better option. Finally, consider the cost and maintenance requirements of each type of pump. Hand pumps are generally less expensive and require less maintenance, but may require more physical effort to operate. Electric pumps are more expensive and require a source of electricity, but are more efficient and require less physical effort to operate.

Making the Final Decision: Which Pump is Right for You?

Ultimately, the decision between a hand well pump and an electric pump comes down to your specific needs and circumstances. Consider factors such as location, physical abilities, water usage, and cost when making your decision. If you live in a remote area without access to electricity and only need to pump small amounts of water, a hand pump may be the best option. However, if you have a deep well and need to pump large amounts of water, an electric pump may be more efficient. It’s important to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each type of pump before making a final decision. Luckily for you, we’re the well pump experts at Carolina Well and Pump. We’d love to talk to you further about your two options and help figure out which will fit your water needs best.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

More To Explore

Well FAQs

Well Water Winterization

While you’re getting your home prepped for guests, is your well ready for the winter? We discuss everything you need to know about preparing your well water for the winter. 

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best